The Hidden Cost of Safety: Banks Charging Fees for Contactless Payments

During the COVID-19 pandemic, you've likely embraced contactless payments to avoid handling cash that has passed through many hands. Banks themselves have promoted this safer, touch-free method. However, a revealing new study by the online portal biallo.de shows a troubling trend: over half of German savings banks (Sparkassen) and cooperative banks (Volks- und Raiffeisenbanken) are now charging extra fees for this very service. If you use a basic checking account, you could be paying significantly more than you realize for everyday convenience.

The Study's Findings: Widespread Fees on Basic Accounts

The investigation examined 380 savings banks and 440 cooperative banks. The key finding is stark: every second financial institution now imposes a fee for cashless payments made with debit or credit cards. These charges typically target customers with low-cost or basic account models, such as the "Girokonto Klassik" (Classic Checking Account). Notably, Germany's largest public savings bank, Hamburger Sparkasse, charges 50 cents per transaction. This practice disproportionately affects customers with limited financial means who rely on these essential accounts.

Understanding the Cost Structure

The average fee per transaction is 34 cents, but the range is wide—from 2 cents to a steep 70 cents at Sparkasse Rhein-Lippe. Crucially, these contactless payment fees are additional costs. The basic accounts themselves often carry a monthly maintenance fee (e.g., typically €5.90 for a "Girokonto Klassik"), even if you don't use any other services.

What might seem like small charges can accumulate dramatically over a year. Biallo provides a clear example: a customer of the "Klassik" account at Niederrheinische Sparkasse Rhein-Lippe in Wesel, making just two contactless payments per day, could face an extra annual burden of €504. This turns a promoted health safety measure into a substantial financial penalty.

The Transparency Problem: Hidden Fees and Poor Communication

Perhaps more frustrating than the fees themselves is the lack of clear communication. The study found that many banks, including Sparkasse am Niederrhein, fail to make their fee schedules readily accessible on their websites—a potential violation of legal disclosure requirements. Customers often only discover these charges upon inquiry or when reviewing their statements.

Niels Nauhauser, a banking expert at the Verbraucherzentrale Baden-Württemberg (Consumer Center), criticizes this practice: "Instead of honestly and openly stating the fees for card payments, they are regularly hidden under booking postings in the price list." This lack of transparency makes it difficult for you to make informed decisions and compare banking products effectively.

What You Can Do: Tips to Manage and Avoid Fees

As a consumer, you have options to protect yourself from these creeping charges:

1. Review Your Account Terms: Carefully check your bank's current price list (Preisverzeichnis). Look for terms like "Kartenzahlung," "Bargeldlose Zahlung," or "Kontaktloses Bezahlen."
2. Consider Switching Accounts: Many direct banks (Direktbanken) and online banks offer checking accounts with no monthly fees and free card payments. Comparing offers can lead to significant savings.
3. Ask Directly: If information is unclear, contact your bank and ask specifically: "Do you charge fees for contactless debit/credit card payments, and if so, how much per transaction?"
4. Use Alternative Payment Methods: For some small, daily purchases, using a mobile payment app linked to your account (like Apple Pay or Google Pay, if supported) might bypass specific card fees, though you should verify this with your bank.
5. Leverage Consumer Resources: Consult independent comparison portals and consumer advice centers for up-to-date information on fair banking practices.

The move towards cashless transactions should not become a pretext for imposing hidden costs on consumers, especially those most vulnerable. By staying informed and proactive, you can ensure that your choice for a safer payment method doesn't come with an unfair financial burden.

Insurers and brokers are struggling in claims management with high backlogs, increasing claim frequencies, a shortage of skilled workers, and growing customer expectations. Manual processes are expensive and slow.